6/7/08

To Jackass Morton Klein - Just Shut Up

If you don't know what you are talking about, it is best to shut up. But Morton Klein knows best doesn't he?

Thinks Klein: "Hey I think I will call Barack Obama an outright liar on the record in the New York Times."

Look Barack. Klein is just a jackass. You can ignore him. We should too.

From the Times: "Obama’s Comments on Israel Stir Criticism in U.S." by LARRY ROHTER...
...Even within Israel, where the speech was overwhelmingly applauded, some analysts suggested Mr. Obama had staked out a position beyond that of current Israeli leaders. One television commentator said his language was reminiscent of former Prime Minister Menachem Begin of the hard-line Likud Party, who signed a peace accord with Egypt but expanded Israeli settlements in the West Bank.

In an interview with CNN on Thursday, Mr. Obama was asked about criticisms from the Arab world, and whether his remarks meant that Palestinians had no claim to Jerusalem.

“Well,” he replied, “obviously it’s going to be up to the parties to negotiate a range of these issues,” including the status of Jerusalem.

While restating his support for an undivided city, he also said, “My belief is that, as a practical matter, it would be very difficult to execute.”

An article on Friday in The Jerusalem Post sought to clarify Mr. Obama’s stance further. In it, an unnamed foreign policy adviser to Mr. Obama was quoted as saying that the candidate’s position is that “Jerusalem remains Israel’s capital and it’s not going to be divided by barbed wire and checkpoints as it was in 1948-1967.”

That formulation does not rule out the city simultaneously serving as the capital of a Palestinian state or Palestinians’ being granted control of some Arab neighborhoods there.

With criticism mounting on Friday from Republicans and some Jewish groups, supporters of Mr. Obama rushed to his defense.

“Barack Obama’s position has been the same for years, and entirely consistent on the campaign,” said Representative Robert Wexler of Florida, one of Mr. Obama’s main bridges to Jewish voters. “He wants a unified Jerusalem that serves as the capital of a Jewish state of Israel, and to extrapolate anything else from that position is inaccurate.”

Mr. Wexler called Mr. Obama’s position the “most pro-Israel of all” because he has promised to respect whatever agreement Israel and Palestinians reach through negotiations rather than impose an American solution.

Dennis Ross, a diplomat who was involved in Middle East peace talks for the administrations of the first President Bush and President Bill Clinton, expressed similar views. Mr. Ross said he saw “no calibration” in Mr. Obama’s stance, which he said “does not contradict in any way, shape or form what our policy has historically been.”

But leaders of some Jewish groups remain unconvinced.

“With Barack Obama and his campaign watering down his statement for an undivided Jerusalem,” said Morton A. Klein, national president of the Zionist Organization of America, “one must question whether his initial remark was simply meant to mislead Jewish voters and Israel supporters by not stating his true beliefs on this issue.”

6 comments:

bryce said...

Your loyal readers haven't forgotten an old post of yours where you decry namecalling.

John D. Enright said...

Oh, no, bryce. He decries only namecalling with which he doesn't agree. So, he can call anybody who disagrees with him "wingnuts." He even as a page collecting all of his wingnut pronouncements. He's got other pet names for people, too. But YOU can't call him a barking moonbat!

John D. Enright said...

Here's what Israel is the greatest by Rabbi Jonathan Ginsburg says: "An article on Friday in The Jerusalem Post sought to clarify Mr. Obama’s stance further. In it, an unnamed foreign policy adviser to Mr. Obama was quoted as saying that the candidate’s position is that 'Jerusalem remains Israel’s capital and it’s not going to be divided by barbed wire and checkpoints as it was in 1948-1967.'
That formulation does not rule out the city simultaneously serving as the capital of a Palestinian state or Palestinians’ being granted control of some Arab neighborhoods there."

Sounds like Klein should NOT shut up at all! He should scream from the tallest mountain.

Tzvee said...

woof woof, i don't deny it. perhaps you should read up on how politics works.

John D. Enright said...

Glad that you don't deny it. It speaks volumes that Obama is full of BS; he says what he thinks his listeners want to hear. It doesn't mean that he has any intention of following through. He is nothing other than hot air.

Tzvee said...

no name-calling, that is his title. that hot-air attack isn't working. hey i guess it is nothing but hot-air.