Is Paul Volcker Jewish?

Forbes reports that Paul Volcker is retiring from public life, "Gone Fishing: Paul Volcker Retires From Public Life, Heads For the River," saying, "Later this week Paul Volcker, the man who helped guide the U.S. through two of its most serious recent economic crises, will step down as the chairman of the President’s Economic Advisory Board."

We do not think that former Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker is a Jew. According to reporter Roni Sofer of the usually reliable Israeli source YNet, he is a Jew. However this is disputed by other credible evidence.

The 2004 biography by Joseph B. Treaster, Paul Volcker: The Making of a Financial Legend, says Volcker attended a Lutheran church on Sundays with his mother, while his father went to an Episcopalian church.

Volcker served on the Obama economic team. WSJ reports that his influence was substantial, "At least for the day, the most powerful man in the U.S. financial industry and for equities markets is 82 years old, a man who ended his leadership of the Federal Reserve more than 20 years ago."

Volcker is a native son of Teaneck New Jersey and a graduate of Teaneck High School. His father was the township's first Municipal manager.

Volcker was appointed Chairman of the Federal Reserve in August 1979 by President Jimmy Carter and reappointed in 1983 by President Ronald Reagan.
//augmented repost from 3/09//

Oh Boy! GPS Tagged Photos on Our Samsung Epic 4G Sprint Phone

We noticed in Picasa a little push pin icon on our Samsung Epic 4G pictures and then we realized whoa, the phone-camera can do GPS tagging. So we poked around until we found the place to enable the GPS tagging: opened the camera, clicked on the gear, then on the wrench then on GPS, to turn it on.

Okay so then we took some pictures today inside Carnegie Hall and when we went to view them in the Gallery app on the phone and clicked on Menu > More > Show on Map, lo and behold there was the map showing the Carnegie Hall location for each picture.

And yes, the camera quality is quite good - the colors are vivid.

Oh boy! We have GPS tagging on our phone photos. See a review of the phone camera here.

Botstein's Unstaged Berenice Opera Okay at Carnegie Hall

If you are married to a Berenice, then you must go to see any opera about Berenice, especially if you receive the tickets as a gift.

So we did go to see the U.S. Premiere of Alberic Magnard's "Berenice" conducted by Leon Botstein and staged by the American Symphony Orchestra at Carnegie Hall today.

The libretto is lightly historical, quite predictable and without undue drama. Blogger Arthur Leonard at Leonard Link reviews the whole shebang with some care summarizing for us the story line,

According to Magnard's plot (he wrote the libretto), after the Romans had conquered ancient Israel, Berenice was brought to Rome, where she became the lover of Titus, the Roman general (and son of Emperor Vespasian). They had a hot five year affair, but then Vespasian fell ill and the moment of truth arrived. Would Titus keep his promise to marry Berenice and make her Empress of Rome when he took office upon his father's death, or would he bow to the demands of patriotic Romans who could not stand a foreigner in the Caesar's palace, and require her to return to her homeland to demonstrate his loyalty to Rome above his personal emotional interests? That's the entire plot of this three-act opera that contains about 2-1/2 hours of music. During the first act they receive news of Vespasian's illness, during the second act Titus agonizes about the terrible choice and gives the bad news to Berenice, and in the third she leaves after a final confrontation with Titus.

Leonard liked the music, as did we, though we found it put us to sleep more than once. We found Botstein's conducting lacking energy and any pretense of drama. Unstaged opera usually seems like a rehearsal and Botstein's effort did little to counter that feeling.

The one scene in which the citizens of Rome call for Berenice to return to Judea smacks of antiSemitism, but does not reach the threshold of actual bigoted singing.

We had a hard time after the show applauding the singer who played Titus. After all he destroyed the Temple, now you want we should applaud him?

Hard to fault the unenthusiastic conducting because it is amazing that Botstein can manage at all to be at once a college president and conduct an orchestra.

Blogger Leonard gushed over the opera. We thought is was an okay plus pleasant afternoon on 57th Street.

Official site here.

AP: Egypt Museum in Danger

From 1983

We haven't been there since 1983 (see above).

Reports are that the Egypt Museum is in danger due to the civil unrest in Cairo.

Egypt Shuts Down its Internet

It's nefarious but logical that Egypt would shut down the Internet during its unrest.

CNN reported what happened and another source, Ars Technica, reported on how easy it was for Egypt to accomplish the shutdown and speculated about whether it could happen here in the US.

ABC: 400 Rabbis Demand End to Nazi Talk

ABC reported that 400 rabbis took an ad out to demand that people stop using Nazi comparisons.

The Other N-Word: Rabbis Unamused. Jewish Clergy Offended by Increasing Use of the Word Nazi to Bash Opponents

This is not a new phenomenon. Years ago Amos Oz in the beginning of his superb book, In the Land of Israel (1983, 1993) decried this rhetorical trend among the Jews in Israel of calling people you don't like Nazis.

The word is not sacred. It's not worth wasting money on a full page ad.

Google Digitizes for the Web Yad Vashem Holocaust Photos and Documents

Hat tip to Barak.

Explore Yad Vashem’s Holocaust archives online

via The Official Google Blog by A Googler on 1/26/11

(Cross-posted on the Google.org Blog)

In honor of the UN International Holocaust Remembrance Day tomorrow, we’re partnering with Yad Vashem, the Jerusalem-based center for remembering the Holocaust's victims and survivors, to bring their collections of photographs and documents to the web.

On a trip to Jerusalem three years ago, Jonathan Rosenberg visited Yad Vashem. Struck by the museum's vast historical record housed within the physical building, he hoped Google could do something powerful to showcase this information. Inspired by the challenge, a few of us, in our “20% time,” started working with Yad Vashem and eventually grew our effort into a full project, introducing a YouTube channel in 2008 and now this collections site.

Within the archive you will find more than 130,000 images in full resolution. You can search for them via a custom search engine on Yad Vashem’s collections site. And by using experimental optical character recognition (OCR), we’ve transcribed the text on many images, making them even more discoverable on the web. This means that if you search for the name of a family member who was in the Holocaust, you might find a link to an image on the Yad Vashem site.

To experience the new archive features yourself, try searching for the term [rena weiser], the name of a Jewish refugee. You’ll find a link to a visa issued to her by the Consulate of Chile in France. OCR technology made this picture discoverable to those searching for her.

Yad Vashem encourages you to add personal stories about images that have meaning for you in the “share your thoughts” section below each item. Doron Avni, a fellow Googler, has already added a story. He found a photograph of his grandfather taken immediately after his release from a Nazi prison. His grandfather had vowed that if he should survive, he would immediately have his picture taken to preserve the memory of his experience in the Holocaust. He stitched the photo into his coat, an act that later saved his life. After hiding in the forest for a year, Russian soldiers mistook him for a German enemy, but released him once they saw this picture.

Bergen Record: Teaneck Approves Boathouse on the Hackensack

It is a given that some people will try their hardest to stop this project - a boathouse on the Hackensack river a block from our house. We don't play tennis and do like water sports of all kinds. So we hope this does go through to reality...

Teaneck OKs boathouse, dock at Andreas Park
BY JOSEPH AX, The Record STAFF WRITER

TEANECK – The town will have its first boathouse and floating dock, after the Township Council approved a proposal to construct them at Andreas Park on the banks of the Hackensack River.

The Teaneck Rowing Club, a nonprofit group that provides equipment for the high school crew team, will build the 2,275-square-foot boathouse as a storage facility for its rowing shells, replacing the park’s current tennis court, and install the dock.

The World's Most Expensive Bible at $130,000 a copy from St. John's in Minnesota

Partly it's because it's handiwork by calligraphers and artists, and partly because it is a fantastic fund raising device, St. John's University is offering copies of their Bible at the discount price of $115,000. But you have to hurry. The Star Tribune reported in 2006:

Some colleges woo supporters with tailgate parties, others with exotic trips. St. John's Abbey and University in Collegeville, Minn., is offering alumni and friends the chance to buy a really big Bible for $115,000. That's the price for orders placed before July 1, 2007. After that the tab jumps to $130,000.

If all of the Bibles sell at the introductory price, they would bring in $41.4 million, minus expenses.

At next year's rate, the school would realize $46.8 million before costs.

While some book experts think the price is steep, St. John's officials are confident that their seven-volume, leather-bound Bible will prove popular.

"We're charting unknown territory to a certain extent, because this is an extremely large set of books, but the response has been wonderful," said Craig Bruner, director of the Heritage Edition, as the college is calling its special book.

The first volume won't be available until 2008, Bruner said, but since August, when the Bible went on sale, 13 sets have been reserved.

St. John's plans to publish just 360 Heritage Bibles, all facsimiles of its original St. John's Bible, a monumental tome that a team of calligraphers is hand-lettering and illustrating. The St. John's Bible is a $4.5 million project the school began in 1998 under the direction of British calligrapher Donald Jackson. He and his 14-member team are producing just one copy of the Bible, which will be housed at St. John's, about 75 miles northwest of Minneapolis.

The Heritage edition will attempt to replicate the 1,150-page, 2-foot-tall original as closely as possible but without the handwork, gold leaf, jeweled inks and rare materials that make the original so costly.

The quite attractive web site for the bible project is here.

Sadly, the man who commissioned the bible and who served as president of St. John's, Brother Dietrich Reinhart, passed away on Monday (12-29-08) after a bout with cancer.

[Reposted and updated from 2006]

Shamma Friedman and the Talmudic Assembly Line

Take a close look at your car. Now write a book mainly about the assembly line that produced that car. You may say a few random and simple things about the car itself. But mostly in your book you must speculate about the people who put it together, and guess how it came into being.

That's similar to what some scholars of the Talmud do with that composite document. It's a wonderful way to free associate a wealth of learning, to wax creative without the possibility that anyone could prove you wrong. You spell out a hypothetical theory about an imaginary assembly line that spanned centuries and produced the Talmud.

Most of all, secular Israeli authorities welcome what you do. There's nothing remotely political or threatening about a Talmud disassembled in pieces on the factory floor of history. And the bearded scholars in the Yeshivas will wonder about the value of that kind of "academic Talmud study" which leaves the compilation in a junkyard heap of nuts and bolts.

Yehuda Mirsky celebrates the work of academic Talmud scholar Shamma Friedman in his article, Talmud: The Back Story. After glowing accolades, he finally in apparent if unrealized exasperation asks about all this busy work of taking apart the engine of the Talmud, "...can we somehow put the pieces back together into a coherent and compelling story? And will that story reflect not only the work of the rabbinic interpreters but also the original texts and traditions, by now lost to us, that they were trying, through their editing, to maintain?" We aren't clear on the substance of Mirsky's questions, but we do share his ultimate sense of frustration.

StarTribune: Beware of the Dangers of Road Rage Even in Winter

We usually think of road rage as a scourge of the summer months. Not so reports the Star Tribune.

Raging driver cuts off, blocks another, allegedly pulls gun

Minneapolis police on Wednesday were investigating a driver's complaint that when he asked another motorist to move his car, the man pulled a gun on him and flew into a rage.

The complainant, Steve Haughton, 41, of Savage, said in an interview that he was driving on 22nd Street E. near Peavey Field in s outh Minneapolis on Tuesday when another vehicle cut him off and blocked his way.

Haughton said he lowered his window and asked the man to move his car. He said the man pulled a gun, threatened him with it and cursed at him loudly. "He just started losing his mind," Haughton said.

Haughton, who never left his pickup, fled and called police, giving them the other vehicle's license plate number.

No arrests had been made Wednesday, but the investigation was continuing, said police spokesman Sgt. Steve McCarty.

Times: Jews Reboot in Exclusive Conference

There is a secretive group called Reboot, which the Times tells us, "since 2002 has conducted an annual conference for young, affluent Jews to discuss their ethnic and religious identity, in between spa treatments and walks among the ponderosa pines of the Wasatch Mountains."

We know little about this conference because we are not in on the secret.

Here is how the Times ends the article.

As prayers were set to begin, an elderly Jewish woman entered, her dress shimmering in the candlelight, her blond bouffant framing the accentuated makeup around her eyes. It was Mr. Lau-Lavie dressed in drag as an incarnation of Esther, the biblical Queen of Persia.

“Drag in its best is court jester,” Mr. Lau-Lavie said. “People are so ambivalent about religion, I thought this was a way to do it.”

Mr. Pollack watched in awe. “It was definitely comic,” he said. Indeed Mr. Lau-Lavie was a hit with many that year.

“He said something about God being a black woman,” Ms. Soloway said. “No one ever said this in temple. I felt like I wanted to follow him around all day. He was like Jim Jones, and I wanted to drink his Kool-Aid.”

Mr. Pollack was less moved by his Reboot experience. “I liked a lot of the people I met there, but I don’t think it changed me,” he said. And Mr. Rushkoff was downright critical. “Its success seems dependent on a certain kind of insidery elitism,” he said. “People don’t want to frame Reboot as an effort to market Judaism to Jews. I think it is hard not to see it as that.” (Mr. Bennett responded: “Reboot is a funny thing. It is different things to different people.”)

Mr. Rollman, for his part, still questions what it means to be a Jew. “Reboot has not provided me a magical solution,” he said. “But it has given me comfort in allowing me to make my relationship with Judaism my own.”

But Ms. Behrman declares herself utterly transformed.

“It’s ridiculous how Jew-y I’ve become,” she said.

Video: Hawaii Senate Proposes to Stop All Religious Invocations; Medved Calls it Insane

The above incident captured on video in April in Hawaii has led to controversy and now a proposed cessation of all religious invocations at the state Senate.

We believe this is a sane and sound proposal. Right wing radical demagogue Michael Medved calls this decision by state legislators "insane".

Hawaii Senate may end religious invocations
HONOLULU (AP) — Hawaii Senate leaders are recommending that the chamber end religious invocations before floor sessions.

The change is meant to respect each individual's religious beliefs, Senate President Shan Tsutsui, D-Wailuku-Kahului, said in Wednesday's editions of The Honolulu Star-Advertiser.

"We respect everybody's different levels of faith and the different religions that they support," Tsutsui said. "We're not making any type of statement, but rather we're respecting each individual's religious beliefs."

The new policy is part of a proposed Senate rules package that will be considered before this year's legislative session begins Jan. 19.

The move away from religious invocations came after a complaint from the American Civil Liberties Union of Hawaii that the invocations often included "decidedly Christian prayers — with reference to Jesus Christ."

The Raw Story: Tea Party Demagogues' Strategy - Blame Giffords, Raise Money

We have two political parties in the country: the Democrats and the Demagogues.

The official Tea Party line is that Giffords was "asking for it" and that the Tea Party should now use the shooting to raise money. Yes, that is what is reported.

Tucson tea party founder says Giffords to blame for getting shot
By David Edwards

One tea party leader says that Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (D-AZ) has herself to blame for getting shot in the head Saturday.

The Arizona congresswoman shouldn't have attended an event "in full view of the public" if she had security concerns, according to Tucson Tea Party co-founder Trent Humphries.

Giffords warned MSNBC's Chuck Todd last year that there would be "consequences" to violent rhetoric and imagery after Fox News' Sarah Palin released a graphic which placed crosshairs over the congresswoman's district.

"But the thing is that the way that [Palin] has it depicted has the crosshairs of a gunsight over our district," Giffords said. "And when people do that, they’ve gotta realize there’s consequences to that action."

But Humphries thinks Giffords was just speaking out against Palin for political gain.

"It's political gamesmanship," he told the Guardian. "The real case is that she [Giffords] had no security whatsoever at this event. So if she lived under a constant fear of being targeted, if she lived under this constant fear of this rhetoric and hatred that was seething, why would she attend an event in full view of the public with no security whatsoever?"

"For all the stuff they accuse [Palin] of, that gun poster has not done a tenth of the damage to the political discourse as what we're hearing right now."

"There are people who are genuinely confused, scared, and I understand it. But there are also people who are deliberately manipulating this event and tragedy for political ends," Humpries added.

And he may be right. Another tea party group in California has been using the tragedy to raise money.

In an e-mail to supporters this week, the Tea Party Express asked for donations.

"Instead of prayers for the victims and their families, the Left was consumed with using this massacre to score political points by blaming the tea party movement, Gov. Sarah Palin and now Rush Limbaugh," the e-mail said.

"That's why we've asked you for your support. Let's show the Left that instead of us being silenced, that there awful attacks on us will only backfire and that the tea party movement will be stronger than ever!"

"Please, make a contribution online right now to the Tea Party Express," the letter concluded.

Is Sarah Palin the Provoker of Violence or the Victim of a Blood Libel?

Here is what Palin says, her own video from her home studio in Alaska. She won't speak to the press.


Here is the crosshairs graphic Palin circulated including Gifford's district. Crosshairs are only used to depict targets, they unambiguously symbolize aiming with a gun.


We report, you decide. Is Sarah Palin the victim of a blood libel?

Reuters: Sarah Palin Disgracefully Accuses Media of Blood Libel Against Her

Sarah Palin is definitely ignorant of what is a blood libel. From Wikipedia, which Sarah could access, if she wished to take off a minute from her incessant attacks:

Blood libel (also blood accusation) refers to a false accusation or claim that religious minorities, almost always Jews, murder children to use their blood in certain aspects of their religious rituals and holidays. Historically, these claims have–alongside those of well poisoning and host desecration–been a major theme in European persecution of Jews.

The libels typically allege that Jews require human blood for the baking of matzos for Passover. The accusations often assert that the blood of Christian children is especially coveted, and historically blood libel claims have often been made to account for otherwise unexplained deaths of children. In some cases, the alleged victim of human sacrifice has become venerated as a martyr, a holy figure around whom a martyr cult might arise. A few of these have been even canonized as saints....

We feel that the profound misuse of this concept by Palin to further her political aims is her most disgraceful act to date.

Sarah Palin accuses critics of "blood libel"

(Reuters) - Prominent Republican Sarah Palin on Wednesday accused critics of "blood libel" by blaming her rhetoric for contributing to the shooting rampage in Tucson that killed six and wounded 14, including Democratic Representative Gabrielle Giffords.

"Acts of monstrous criminality stand on their own. They begin and end with the criminals who commit them," the conservative Tea Party favorite and former Alaska governor said in her first major response to critics.

"Especially within hours of a tragedy unfolding, journalists and pundits should not manufacture a blood libel that serves only to incite the very hatred and violence they purport to condemn. That is reprehensible."...more...

USA Today Faith & Reason: AntiSemitism and the Gifford Shooting - with link to Tzvee

The USA Today Faith and Reason blog discusses antiSemitism and the Gifford shooting - with a link to Tzvee's Talmudic Blog (link for "Jewish Women", third indented paragraph, is to this blog...).

Jewish Giffords' shooting suspect: 'No! I don't trust in God!'

We read the story early today but missed the link.

We are praying for her speedy and complete recovery.

Hat tip to Joseph for catching that link.

Updated: Use the Vulkano iPad or Android App to connect to your Hava Titanium HD TV Device with WiFi

The company that makes the Hava TV place shifter has discontinued that model and come our with the Vulkano, an HD upgrade with several models.

We were bummed out to learn that there would be no support or update for the Hava... until we happily discovered by chance that you can download the free app for the Vulkano for an iPad, iPod or Android device... and you can log in and it will pick up your Hava feed and display it on your device.

See more about the iPad app and android app and other players here.

From December 2009:

Didn't get what you wanted for the holidays? Try this neat device.

Mandatory Joke. No, they do not have a Hava Nagilah model.

Is Rep. Gabrielle Giffords Jewish?

Yes Rep. Gabrielle Giffords (D-Ariz.) is a Jew. She was shot in the head at a political event in Tucson on Jan. 8, 2011.

JTA reports:

Giffords was elected to Congress in the Democratic sweep in 2006. The first Jewish woman elected to Congress from the state, she made her Jewish identity part of her campaign.

“If you want something done, your best bet is to ask a Jewish woman to do it,” said Giffords, a former state senator, said at the time. “Jewish women — by our tradition and by the way we were raised — have an ability to cut through all the reasons why something should, shouldn’t or can’t be done and pull people together to be successful.”

Giffords, 40, was raised "mixed" by a Christian Scientist mother and Jewish father, but said that after a visit to Israel in 2001, she had decided she was Jewish only. She attended services at a local Reform synagogue.

In one of her last photos, she posed with the new U.S. House of Representatives speaker, Rep. John Boehner (R-Ohio) at her swearing in; her hand is on the "Five Books of Moses."

Thank You Grebelius Redivivus Blog for Ranking us 9th

We thank Jim East of the Grebelius Redivivus Blog for ranking us 9th in The biblioblog rankings for December: The Top 20.

We cannot argue the ranking, since the blog tells us, "The Urim and Thummim have spoken. Anathema on those who deny these holy decreed biblioblog rankings. Amen."

Review: Avishai David presents Rav Soloveitchik's lectures on the Weekly Torah Readings

Discourses of Rav Yosef Dov Halevi Soloveitchik on the Weekly Parashah by Rabbi Avishai David

This book is a thoroughly rabbinic treat.

It is written by Avishai David, a prominent rabbi who heads a Yeshiva in Israel. It is about the lectures on the weekly torah readings of Rav Joseph B. Soloveitchik, a great gadol of the past generation whose charismatic Torah teachings mesmerized his followers. Rav Soloveitchik was also our teacher when we studied at Yeshiva University.

The Rav draws liberally on the teachings of the ancient rabbis and advances his own insights into the biblical texts.

And the final rabbinic ingredient to this rabbinic feast of a book is the source of publication, the rabbinical authorities at the Orthodox Union who published the book in conjunction with Yeshiva Torat Shraga and the exceptionally gifted Urim Publications of Jerusalem and New York.

The Rav was a man of great dignity and propriety and would have been proud to see the professional manner in which his teachings have been brought together in this volume. It is a handsomely set and bound book, tightly edited and written in impeccable English, with the right level of style for the content that it conveys.

The book brilliantly represents the Rav's Torah as he presented it. This means that it will be a great gift to those of his followers who thirst to hear and read his concepts as they were given over.

And this is the pièce de résistance of the rabbinic feast encompassed in this volume. It will serve future generations as the template or palette for rabbis who wish to use the Rav's content as the springboard from which to develop their own commentaries and as the raw materials for those who elect to build their own structures out of the basic original ideas of Rav Soloveitchik as represented in this book.

We commend the book highly to individuals and to libraries.

Is Robert Gibbs Jewish?

No, Barack Obama's former White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs is not a Jew.

Gibbs was born in Auburn, Alabama on March 29, 1971. He is married to Mary Catherine Gibbs, an attorney. They live in Alexandria, Virginia with their six-year-old son. Gibbs' parents now live in Apex, North Carolina, where his mother Nancy is acquisitions director for the libraries at Duke University.

Of note, Gibbs went on a tirade in 2009 against Sean Hannity, the Fox News host, on his show to prove the vacuity of charges of guilt by association that were being leveled at Barack Obama. To make his point, Gibbs forcefully charged that Hannity was an anti-Semite because he had previously had on an anti-Semitic guest.

Is David Axelrod Jewish?

Yes, David Axelrod who has resigned as President Barack Obama’s Senior Adviser in the White House, is a Jew.

He grew up in a middle-class Jewish household in New York's Stuyvesant Town neighborhood. Axelrod showed a passion for politics at age 13 when he sold campaign buttons for Robert F. Kennedy. Axelrod attended Stuyvesant High School in Manhattan and the University of Chicago.

Former White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, who is also Jewish, is one of Axelrod’s closest friends. Axelrod signed the ketubah (Jewish marriage contract) at Emanuel’s wedding, an honor usually reserved for a close personal friend (TNR: The Plank).

Bibi Loves Pollard, Who by the way is no Dreyfus

Isn't love grand?

Israeli PM Bibi Netanyahu loves Jonathan Pollard and has written a letter asking for his release from federal prison in the United States.

This just made us want to compare the historic Dreyfus Affair with its contrasting opposite, the modern Pollard Affair.

Let's see. The two start out similar. Both men were Jews who were accused of spying against their own countries.

Dreyfus was sentenced in 1894 to life imprisonment for allegedly having communicated French military secrets to the German Embassy in Paris, and was sent to the penal colony at Devil's Island and placed in solitary confinement.

Pollard was sentenced in 1987 to life imprisonment for allegedly having communicated American military secrets to the Israelis, and was sent to the federal prison and placed in solitary confinement.

Two years later evidence implicated someone else as the culprit in the French affair. But Dreyfus was further accused by the French Army with fabricated evidence.

Pollard admitted his crimes. Nobody ever claims that he was framed.

In his famed J'accuse letter, the writer Emile Zola exposed the framing of Dreyfus and the cover up of exculpatory evidence . The fallout from this affair divided French society.

The confessed spy Pollard tried to get Wolf Blitzer to interview him in prison. This infuriated the US authorities.

Dreyfus was fully exonerated and reinstated in the Army where he served with honor.

Pollard wants to be freed because he says he is really sorry and he has been in a nasty jail a really long time.

In the end the Dreyfus affair exposed the antiSemitism of European society and stimulated the Zionism of Theodor Herzl, which in turn led to the ultimate founding of the State of Israel.

In the end the Pollard affair is eroding the political credibility of all those Zionists who express support for him, in particular Bibi Netanyahu. We think it is seriously damaging the Zionist cause.

Just what motivates this present self-defeating behavior? We simply have no clue.

Times: Aharon Friedman refuses to divorce his wife

Slow news day alert.

According to the Times, Aharon Friedman refuses to divorce his wife. Actually they are divorced according to civil law. Friedman refuses to give his wife a religious divorce.

We've for a long while thought that the refusal of the rabbis to correct this inequity of Jewish law was especially nasty. A Jewish man can divorce his wife by giving her a get. But the wife has no power to initiate a Jewish divorce.

While the law of divorce may be based at some ultra general level on Torah law revealed to Moses at Sinai, we don't think Moses would mind if rabbis allowed some additional leeway to American women in the 21st century. Seriously.

Religious Divorce Dispute Leads to Secular Protest
By MARK OPPENHEIMER
This should have been a good New Year’s for Aharon Friedman, a 34-year-old tax counsel for the Republicans on the House Ways and Means Committee. He spent time with his 3-year-old daughter, and could have been thinking about the influence he will have starting Wednesday, when his boss, Representative Dave Camp of Michigan, becomes chairman of the powerful tax-writing committee.

Instead, Mr. Friedman, an Orthodox Jew, finds himself scrutinized in the Jewish press, condemned by important rabbis, and attacked in a YouTube video showing about 200 people protesting outside his Silver Spring, Md., apartment on Dec. 19. They were angered by Mr. Friedman’s refusal to give his wife, Tamar Epstein, 27, a Jewish decree of divorce, known as a get.

The Friedman case has become emblematic of a torturous issue in which only a husband can “give” a get. While Jewish communities have historically pressured obstinate husbands to give gets, this was a very rare case of seeking to shame the husband in the secular world.

Holding signs saying, “Do the right thing” and “Free your wife,” the crowd included religious women with their heads covered, men in skullcaps and a rabbi with a bullhorn who shouted, “Withholding a get is abusive.” ...more...

Was the Lubavitcher Rebbe the Messiah?

Was the Lubavitcher Rebbe the Messiah?

Maybe. It depends.

If you look at the top of the page of this article on the official Chabad Lubavitch website, it has a banner that says, "Long live our master, our teacher, our rabbi, the messiah king, forever!"

But if you look down below at the article on the page, published today, you find the question and answer on the topic of, "Why hasn't Moshiach come yet?"

Confused? You should be. He was, he wasn't.

Forward: Haredim Reject Curriculum

The Forward fails to tell us what in the curriculum the Haredim find dangerous or contrary to Torah. Must be that they think everyone knows that already. We don't.

Haredi Schools Resist Israel’s Efforts To Impose Core Curriculum

Tel Aviv — A tug-of-war is taking place over the government’s attempt to impose a core curriculum in ultra-Orthodox elementary and high schools, and it’s not just about education. It cuts to the heart of a bitter conflict within Israeli society on the issue of authority.

Israel’s Education Ministry has launched a zero-tolerance policy aimed at Haredi schools that refuse to teach the ministry’s prescribed secular studies curriculum.

But a fight over course content has quickly morphed into something broader. As Jerusalem rabbi Nachum Eisenstein told the Forward: “Rabbis are the ones who decide how to educate in accordance with the principles of the Torah as received on Mount Sinai…. No outside person has any right whatsoever to tell us how to run our education.”

Eisenstein, a confidant of Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, the influential rabbi who has led the battle cry against changes to Haredi curricula, said of the Education Ministry and the high court petitioners, “They want to undermine our education system, which controls the values that are given to our children.”  Read more...

Is the term "morphed" helpful here? We think not. It seems like the Haredim decided to respond to all questions with rhetoric rather than substance. And the Forward is happy to grab onto the rhetorical outbursts and use them to make the Haredim look like uncooperative administrators, which is what they are.

But we want to know what specifics of the curriculum are contrary to what these rabbis believe are the principles that they received on Mount Sinai? We'd like it if the Forward would leave out the rhetoric that they are being fed, and ask some substantive questions. It's time to do that.

Happy New Year MMXI To All Our Friends

Happy New Year MMXI To All Our Friends

Times: Tobi Kahn's Meaningful End-of-life Art

Samuel Freedman in "On Religion" profiles Tobi Kahn's meaningful end-of-life Art. Kahn is a well-known artist and an Orthodox Jew from the German Jewish community in Washington Heights.

We see some of Mr. Kahn's evocative sculptures nearly every day on the grounds of the JCC in Tenafly, New Jersey.

The touching Times article describes how Kahn came to focus on end-of-life art and describes some of what it comprises for this artist. From the article:

This end-of-life artwork also expresses Mr. Kahn’s religious sensibilities, both his lifelong observance of Orthodox Judaism and his commitment to outreach across denominational lines. While his selection for a group show at the Guggenheim in 1985 established his reputation, his work has also been exhibited at such sites as the Museum of Biblical Art in New York and the Museum of Contemporary Religious Art in St. Louis.

“One of the common bonds across traditions is the human concern with suffering, love, mortality, immortality,” said the Rev. Terrence E. Dempsey, director of the St. Louis museum. “The role of religious art at the end of life is that it helps us focus on what’s really important — an interior healing, even if there is no physical healing, and finally a sense of gratitude.”

Having already created art for hospices, hospitals and memorial chapels, art ranging from a single canvas to an entire room for meditation, Mr. Kahn has several significant commissions in the near future. The Educational Alliance, a social service center on the Lower East Side, has retained him to create a 10th-anniversary memorial to victims of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. The HealthCare Chaplaincy has selected him as the principal artist for a 120-unit palliative care residence to be built in Lower Manhattan....more...

Hat tip to Bernice for bringing this article to our attention.